Salt-Water Sandals Review: Styles, Sizing and Care

This guide contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Rope-sole espadrilles from above

Salt-Water Sandals are the simple leather fisherman-style sandals many people remember from childhood. They are made by Hoy Shoe Co. in St. Louis and come in kids’ and adult sizes. This guide covers the history, the main styles, how sizing works and how to care for them.

In this guide
  1. Where Salt-Water Sandals come from
  2. Can you wear them in water?
  3. Main Salt-Water styles
  4. Salt-Water Sandals to look at
  5. How Salt-Water Sandals fit
  6. Care tips
  7. Related guides
  8. Frequently asked questions

Short answer: Salt-Water Sandals are a good pick for a durable leather sandal you can get wet. The Original and Sweetheart are the classic styles, and the Sun-San line adds a cushioned sole. Sizing is unusual, so read the fit notes below before you order.

Where Salt-Water Sandals come from

Hoy Shoe Co. in St. Louis has made the sandals since 1944. The story goes that the first pair was made from scraps of leather left over from WWII military boots, for Walter Hoy’s daughter. The family business still runs the brand today.

Some pairs are made in St. Louis and some are made in China, so check the product page if made-in-USA matters to you.

Rope-sole espadrilles from above
Simple summer sandals are easy to pair with shorts and dresses.

Can you wear them in water?

Yes. The leather is treated to be water resistant and the buckles are rust-proof, so you can wear them at the beach, in creeks and at the pool. Rinse them in fresh water after salt water and let them dry in the shade.

Main Salt-Water styles

Style Look Best for
Original Closed toe, fisherman style Classic everyday wear
Sweetheart Heart-shaped cutouts Kids and dressier looks
Sun-San Sailor Closed toe, cushioned sole More comfort for long days
Sun-San Surfer Open toe, cushioned sole Beach and pool
Retro and Shark Open designs Casual summer wear

Related: How to Clean Converse Shoes: Canvas, Rubber and Laces

Salt-Water Sandals to look at

Salt-Water Original

Best for: Classic kids and adult sandal

The closed-toe fisherman sandal the brand is known for.

  • Good: Durable, water-friendly leather
  • Less good: Firm at first

Check price on Amazon

Salt-Water Sweetheart

Best for: Kids’ dressier summer wear

Heart cutouts and the same leather build.

  • Good: Cute and long lasting
  • Less good: Sizing can be tricky

Check price on Amazon

Sun-San Sailor

Best for: Extra cushioning

A softer sole for long days on foot.

  • Good: More comfortable out of the box
  • Less good: Slightly bulkier look

Check price on Amazon

Close-up of moisturizer being applied to a foot
Leather sandals feel best when your feet are cared for.

How Salt-Water Sandals fit

The brand uses lasts from the 1940s, so the fit is not like a sneaker. The sandal should be snug at the heel, and your toes should sit on or just behind the front stitching. The leather softens and relaxes with wear.

If your child is between sizes, many parents size up for growing room, but too much length can make the sandal slip. Use the brand’s size chart and measure feet first.

  • Measure foot length in the afternoon
  • Check the heel is snug and the toes are at the stitch line
  • Expect a short break-in for new leather

Care tips

  • Rinse after salt water or chlorine
  • Air-dry away from direct heat
  • Use a mild leather conditioner now and then
  • Wipe mud off with a damp cloth

This review is based on the brand’s published information, retailer details and common owner feedback. We have not been paid by the brand. Policies, prices and models change, so check the brand’s site before you buy. Links to Amazon are affiliate links, which support the site at no extra cost to you.

Read types of sandals explained.

Read best sandals for walking.

Read how to clean sandals.

Frequently asked questions

Are Salt-Water Sandals waterproof?

They are water resistant and made to be worn in water. Rinse and air-dry them after use.

Do Salt-Water Sandals run small?

They fit differently from sneakers. Aim for a snug heel and toes at the front stitching, and follow the brand’s size chart.

Where are Salt-Water Sandals made?

Hoy Shoe Co. is based in St. Louis. Some styles are made there and some are made in China.

Do the sandals stretch?

The leather softens and relaxes with wear, so a snug fit at first is normal.

Are they good for toddlers?

Many parents use them for summer. Choose the correct size and check fit often as feet grow. This is general information, not medical advice.

Related Guides