“Why does my left shoe always come untied?” is a question people ask on Reddit and Quora all the time. It turns out scientists have studied it. Mechanical engineers at UC Berkeley published a study on shoelace knots in 2017. Here is what they found and how to keep your laces tied.
In this guide
Short answer: Two things work together: your foot hitting the ground loosens the knot, and your leg swinging pulls on the loose ends and loops. Together they can undo a knot in seconds once it starts to slip. A stronger knot, double knotting and the right laces help a lot.
What the Berkeley study found
The study came from the lab of Oliver O’Reilly, a mechanical engineering professor, with graduate students Christopher Daily-Diamond and Christine Gregg. It was published in Proceedings of the Royal Society A. They filmed runners and studied knots on a pendulum.
Their key finding: the impact of the foot on the ground loosens the knot, and the swinging leg pulls on the free ends and loops. The researchers said you seem to need both forces for the knot to fail. Once it starts to loosen, it can come apart very quickly.

Weak knot vs strong knot
NPR’s report on the study explained that a common way of tying makes the bow sit vertically along the shoe, which comes undone more easily. A strong version makes the bow sit across the shoe. The study found both kinds fail in the same basic way, but the strong one holds better.
| Knot | Bow position | Holds? |
|---|---|---|
| Granny knot (weak) | Bow sits up and down the shoe | Comes undone more easily |
| Square knot base (strong) | Bow sits across the shoe | Holds better |
| Double knot | Extra knot on top | Holds well, harder to untie |
| Ian knot / surgeon’s knot | Extra wrap | Very secure |
Why one shoe comes untied more
If it is always the same shoe, you may tie that side with a different motion, or your stride may hit harder on that side. Try tying both shoes with the same strong knot and watch the difference.
Related: How to Clean White Leather Shoes and Keep Them White
Laces and lace locks
Flat cotton laces
Best for: Everyday sneakers
Flat laces grip better than round slippery laces.
- Good: Cheap, many colors
- Less good: Wear out over time
Elastic no-tie laces
Best for: Kids and runners
Elastic laces with a lock so you never retie.
- Good: Never come undone
- Less good: Less precise fit
Lace locks
Best for: Running and hiking
Small clips that hold laces in place.
- Good: Fast and secure
- Less good: Look sporty

How to keep laces tied
- Tie the starting knot the opposite way to how you usually do, so the bow sits across the shoe
- Double knot for running and sports
- Use flat or textured laces instead of round slippery ones
- Replace worn laces that have gone smooth
- Try lace locks or elastic laces for running
This guide is based on published sources and common owner feedback. Links to Amazon are affiliate links, which support the site at no extra cost to you.
Related guides
Read how to hide shoelaces.
Frequently asked questions
Why do my shoelaces keep coming untied?
UC Berkeley researchers found that foot impact loosens the knot and leg swing pulls the ends. Both together undo the knot.
Why does my left shoe always come untied?
You may tie that side differently or strike harder on that side. Tie both with the same strong knot.
What knot stays tied best?
A knot where the bow sits across the shoe holds better than one where it sits up and down. A double knot holds even better.
Do flat laces stay tied better?
Flat and textured laces usually grip better than round, slippery ones.
Who studied shoelaces coming untied?
Oliver O’Reilly, Christopher Daily-Diamond and Christine Gregg at UC Berkeley.



